Hey readers,
I Fought the Law is a powerful four‑part drama that airs on ITV and is available to stream on ITVX.
The show is an Adaptation from Ann Ming’s gripping memoir, For the Love of Julie.
This true‑story drama unpacks her courageous, 15‑year‑long campaign to overturn the archaic double jeopardy law after her daughter Julie was brutally murdered in 1989.
Sheridan Smith as Ann Ming.
Heart‑Shattering Performance and at the heart of this drama is Sheridan Smith’s performance, which critics are already hailing as one of her finest.
The Times calls her portrayal agonisingly raw, especially in the moment Ann discovers her daughter’s body as if you were there with her in that tiny bathroom.
The Guardian adds that no one does this kind of drama better.
The Financial Times praised her transformation, noting how her performance conveys Ann’s journey from grief to legal reformer, and added that it includes a poignant touch: a cameo from the real Ann Ming herself.
Smith’s ability to embody Ming’s grief, anger, and determination, subtle in some moments, seismic in others, anchors the series emotionally.
Her presence is stolid and delicate, giving the audience insight into a mother’s unbreakable spirit.
Supporting Cast & Emotional Nuance.
The supporting roles add layers of quiet empathy and strength.
Daniel York Loh delivers a beautifully nuanced performance as Charlie Ming, Ann’s husband portraying grief that simmers beneath the surface.
Victoria Wyant plays Julie Hogg in flashback, illustrating the life Ann lost.
Rather than arming the drama with sensational police procedurals, the show speaks to the emotional toll of legal failure and bureaucratic indifference.
Digital Spy praises this care in tone, noting how flashbacks and hallucinations are cleverly peppered throughout to enrich the storytelling in a moving way.
These stylistic choices serve the story, offering a brief respite from sorrow while deepening emotional impact.
True Tale, Dramatised with Respect.
The creators balance fidelity to Ann’s memoir with the narrative demands of television.
The script is rooted deeply in Ann’s book and supported largely by Ming herself.
The production even involved reviewing photographs, letters, and scripts with Ming to maintain authenticity.
That said, small alterations like changing certain names such as Julie’s estranged husband from Andrew to Matthew, or merging and streamlining characters have been made for storytelling clarity.
The drama remains honest to spirit and history, with a clear message that Ann's emotional journey is always foreground over legal technicalities.
The Emotional Core: Grief, Injustice, and Triumph.
The show’s emotional core centres on the intersection of personal tragedy and systemic failure.
Two miss trials left Julie’s killer, William ‘Billy’ Dunlop, free to boast of his immunity under the double jeopardy law.
For years, Ann refused to be sidelined, confronting police, the Crown Prosecution Service, government officials, and even the Justice system itself to force legal change.
Eventually, her perseverance paid off: the law changed in 2005, allowing retrials upon new evidence.
Dunlop became the first person convicted under the revised law in 2006.
In recognition of her efforts, Ann Ming was awarded an MBE in 2007.
Technical Craft and Direction.
Under the guidance of writer Jamie Crichton (All Creatures Great and Small, Grantchester) and director Erik Richter Strand (The Crown), the series achieves a respectful, understated tone that refrains from sensationalism.
Its pacing, atmosphere, and muted visual style underscore the solemnity and gravity of the story.
Filming took place in the North East of England in locations like Teesside, Middlesbrough, Hartlepool, and Newcastle to anchor the drama in the real landscape where these events unfolded.
The local authenticity adds texture to the narrative, reflecting regional character and lived history.
Emotional Resonance with Audiences and Critics.
Across the board, the show has received widespread acclaim:
The Times calls it unforgettable, naming Smith’s performance as one of her best ever.
The Guardian praises its emotional resonance and authenticity, especially balancing grief and legal history.
Financial Times emphasises the drama’s power and Smith’s standout performance but also its refusal to shy from grief and resilience.
Digital Spy hails it as hard and heart‑wrenching yet impossibly compelling.
Final Thoughts.
I Fought the Law is not a flashy true‑crime spectacle; it’s a sombre, dignified, and deeply human meditation on justice, suffering, and perseverance.
Sheridan Smith leads with a performance that is both heart‑shattering and galvanising, and she’s well‑supported by a cast that understands the weight of real‑life grief.
The production values, the writing, the grounding in authentic emotion and place all contribute to a respectful and compelling piece of storytelling.
This is a drama that centres on the human cost of injustice and the power of one woman’s resilience, offering a lesson in dignity, courage, and change.
Cheers for reading X
No comments